15 January 2025

Dismissal and compensation for performing ancillary activities during illness

15 January 2025

Article 7:653a of the Civil Code dictates that an employer may not prohibit or restrict an employee from performing ancillary activities  unless there is an objective reason for doing so. How does this clause work in practice, specifically when an employee is sick?   

The effect of the ancillary activities clause 

Ancillary activities are activities that an employee performs outside of his work. In principle, ancillary activities are permitted. In practice, the clause often includes the condition that an employee may only perform ancillary activities with the prior consent of the employer. 

The employer may only refuse such consent if he has an objective justification. Examples of such an objective justification included in the law are: 

  • the health and safety of the employee; 
  • the protection of confidentiality of company information; 
  • the integrity of public services; 
  • the avoidance of conflicts of interest; and 
  • the violation of a legal requirement.  

The employer does not have to include the objective reason in the employment contract but must provide it when invoking the agreed-upon clause. 

Performing ancillary activities during illness 

Suppose an employee is sick and the employer finds out that this employee is performing ancillary activities. How does a judge rule in such a situation? In a case before the District Court of The Hague, an employee of the municipality of Amsterdam reports in sick. This employee is receiving  benefits due to occupational disability of 80-100%.  

In July 2022, this employee reports in sick for her reintegration work due to a corona infection. The employer submits a termination request to the Netherlands Employees Insurance Agency (UWV) due to  long-term disability, but it is rejected because recovery is considered possible within 26 weeks. In October 2023, the employer again applies for a dismissal permit, which is then rejected because it turns out that the employee has been performing similar work at the Municipality of Rotterdam. An integrity investigation follows which shows that the employee has been working 24 hours a week at the Municipality of Rotterdam , which she did not report as stated in the absence protocol and code of conduct of the Municipality of Amsterdam.

The Subdistrict Court ruled that the employee had violated Section 8 of the Civil Servants Act, which constitutes a breach of contract. The employee should have reported her intention to enter the service of the Municipality of Rotterdam. The employee should also explicitly have  asked permission to do so, and should have reported this to the company doctor. What was reported by the company doctor cannot be interpreted in any other way than that there was (a degree of) intent on the part of the employee to mislead the company doctor and therefore also the municipality. The overpaid wages must be repaid by the employee (Section 7:629 (5) of the Dutch Civil Code). The employment contract is terminated, without awarding the transitional compensation. 

Practical tips for employers 

Although the inclusion an ancillary activities clause employee may be important, an employer can also take steps in the situation where no clause is agreed upon but the employee does perform ancillary activities  during illness. The employer has several options depending on the situation. The employer may have grounds to  dismiss the employee either by instant dismissal or through a termination  procedure in court. In the latter case, the employer can choose to terminate  the employment contract for breach of contract. The options are highly intertwined with the circumstances of the case; in some cases, the employer has to tolerate that the sick employee also performs work elsewhere. 

Contact

Would you like to know more about ancillary activities? Feel free to contact Gerard Zuidgeest, Rose Horstman or one of our other specialists in employment law. Do you have another question? With expertise in eighteen areas of law, La Gro is happy to assist  you.

Author
G.B.M. (Gerard) Zuidgeest

Attorney at Law & Partner

Author
Mr. R.W.E. (Rose) Horstman

Attorney at Law